Section 4 Constitution Pakistan, Article 1212 Service Tribunal Appeal Appeal Appeal against dismissal of a fine which was dismissed, which was dismissed from employment, was reinstated by minor penalty, it was restored. Later, the appellant was retired from employment after attaining the age of office. By the process of recovering the pensionary benefits, the appellant found that he had been fined for the receipt of the money. That, in view of the order of reinstatement of the appellate tribunal filed by the appellant before the service under which the appellant was fined, it cannot be said that the minor penalty was the result of a separate charge. A separate department inquiry should have been initiated for the service tribunal to examine all aspects. Properly case no illegal or irregularities exist Unknown order and as such no interference was required
