Sections 8 (J) and 17 (F) Declaration of the highest rank among students of the Federal Board of Intermediate and Secondary Education Rules for Examinations, R1 19 Constitution Pakistan, Article 199 Constitution Request Higher Secondary School Certificate (HSSC) And the Respondent appeared in the HSSC Examination, under which the Respondent has obtained 914 marks out of 1400, which was declared as the first position holder, after which, to improve its numbers. The aspirant applicant benefited from appearing in the exam again and got 927 marks out of 1400. The applicant believed that because he received high marks and was thus entitled to be the first position holder, he rejected the applicant's claim according to the Federal Board of Intermediate and Secondary Education policy guidelines / rules. In the exam, the repeater did not deserve a legitimate candidate, who got high marks once and forwards, but could not be equal to anyone, who though got the highest number, but through the board's repeated decision, the applicant. Refusing to be called a first position holder is in accordance with the spirit of natural justice Was justified, the doctrine of rational reason and therefore could not be interpreted as objectionable, perverse and irrational and this was based on rational discrimination The constitutional application was dismissed.